James Longstreet: Lee's Old War Horse And A Figure Of Enduring Controversy
Perhaps no Confederate officer is surrounded by more controversy than James Longstreet. A towering figure in the American Civil War, he was revered by his commander, Robert E. Lee, who famously called him "my old war horse." Yet, his legacy is far from simple, marked by strategic disagreements, post-war political shifts, and a reevaluation that continues to this day. Understanding James Longstreet means delving into the complexities of a man who navigated the brutal realities of war and the tumultuous aftermath of Reconstruction, often standing against the prevailing sentiments of his time.
From his early life in the Deep South to his pivotal role in some of the Civil War's most iconic battles, and finally to his controversial post-war career, James Longstreet's story is a compelling narrative of loyalty, defiance, and an unwavering commitment to his convictions. He was a general whose tactical prowess was undeniable, but whose willingness to challenge the prevailing narrative and embrace change made him an "apostate" in the eyes of many. This article will explore the life, career, and enduring legacy of one of the Confederacy's most successful, yet often misunderstood, generals.
Table of Contents
- Early Life and Military Beginnings
- Biographical Data: James Longstreet
- The Civil War: A Confederate General Rises
- Longstreet's Role in Key Campaigns
- Gettysburg: The Unwelcome Truth
- Post-War Life: Controversy and Redemption
- The Legacy of James Longstreet
- Conclusion: A Complex Legacy
Early Life and Military Beginnings
James Longstreet was born on January 8, 1821, in the Edgefield District of South Carolina. His parents were James Longstreet, a planter, and Mary Ann Dent. Although born in South Carolina, Longstreet always considered himself a Georgian, having spent his early years in Augusta, Georgia, not far from his birthplace. This early upbringing in the Deep South would shape his initial allegiances, but his later life would see him challenge many of the prevailing views of that region.
His path to military distinction began with his acceptance into the prestigious United States Military Academy at West Point, New York. He was an 1842 graduate of the institution, a class that included several future Civil War generals, both Union and Confederate. After graduating, Longstreet was brevetted as a second lieutenant and assigned to the 4th U.S. Infantry on July 1, 1842. He then spent four years serving in the American West before being transferred to the 8th U.S. Infantry. It was during the Mexican-American War that Longstreet truly began to make a name for himself, displaying conspicuous bravery that earned him recognition and set the stage for his future military career. This period of service forged him into the "soldier every inch" that Moxley Sorrel would later describe, a man of strong character and undeniable military bearing.
Biographical Data: James Longstreet
| Attribute | Detail |
|---|---|
| Full Name | James Longstreet |
| Born | January 8, 1821 |
| Birthplace | Edgefield District, South Carolina, U.S. |
| Parents | James Longstreet (father), Mary Ann Dent (mother) |
| Considered Himself | A Georgian |
| Alma Mater | United States Military Academy at West Point (Class of 1842) |
| Pre-Civil War Service | U.S. Army (4th U.S. Infantry, 8th U.S. Infantry) |
| Notable Pre-War Conflict | Mexican-American War (displayed conspicuous bravery) |
| Civil War Affiliation | Confederate States of America |
| Highest Rank (Confederate) | Lieutenant General |
| Nickname | "Old Pete," "My Old War Horse" (by Gen. Robert E. Lee) |
| Post-War Affiliation | Republican Party |
| Post-War Role | Supported Black voting and interracial governance during Reconstruction |
| Died | January 2, 1904 |
The Civil War: A Confederate General Rises
The outbreak of the American Civil War dramatically altered the lives of many U.S. Army officers, including James Longstreet. When his native state of South Carolina seceded from the Union in December 1860, followed by Georgia, Longstreet resigned from the U.S. Army to join the Confederate cause. This decision, common among Southern officers, placed him on a path that would intertwine his fate with the Confederacy's most iconic general, Robert E. Lee.
He was quickly made a brigadier general in the Confederate army, a testament to his reputation and experience. From the outset, Longstreet proved to be a formidable commander. Moxley Sorrel, a cavalry officer who joined Longstreet's staff at the beginning of the war, provided a vivid description of the general: "a most striking figure, about forty years of age, a soldier every inch, and very handsome, tall and well proportioned, strong and active, a superb horseman and with an unsurpassed soldierly bearing, his features and expression fairly matched." This image of a physically imposing and highly capable officer quickly translated into battlefield success. Longstreet's strategic mind, his ability to organize and lead large bodies of troops, and his calm demeanor under fire quickly earned him the trust and respect of his superiors, most notably General Robert E. Lee. Lee, who called him "his old war horse" and "Old Pete," came to rely heavily on Longstreet as his trusted advisor and friend, especially as the war progressed and the stakes grew ever higher.
Longstreet's Role in Key Campaigns
James Longstreet's military career during the Civil War was marked by his involvement in nearly every major engagement of the Army of Northern Virginia. His tactical acumen and ability to execute complex maneuvers made him indispensable to Lee. While often known for his defensive prowess, Longstreet was a versatile commander capable of both offensive and defensive operations, adapting his style to the demands of the battlefield.
From the Peninsula to Maryland
Longstreet played a significant role in the early campaigns of the war, contributing to the Confederacy's successes in the Peninsula Campaign and the subsequent Maryland Campaign. His divisions consistently performed well, demonstrating discipline and resilience. During these early engagements, Longstreet's reputation as a steady and reliable commander solidified. He was known for his methodical approach to warfare, preferring to fight defensively from strong positions and then launch powerful counterattacks. This approach often conserved Confederate manpower, a precious resource that the Union, with its larger population, could more easily replenish.
The Northern Virginia Campaign of August 1862
In the Northern Virginia Campaign of August 1862, which culminated in the Second Battle of Manassas (Second Bull Run), Longstreet's role was particularly noteworthy. In this campaign, he did not play his customary defensive role he is most well known for. Instead, Longstreet executed a massive flanking maneuver that shattered the Union left flank and decisively turned the tide of the battle in the Confederacy's favor. This aggressive and highly successful offensive action demonstrated his versatility as a commander and his willingness to take calculated risks when the situation called for it. His performance at Second Manassas cemented his position as Lee's most trusted corps commander, a bond that would be tested and strained at the most crucial juncture of the war.
Gettysburg: The Unwelcome Truth
The Battle of Gettysburg remains the most contentious chapter in James Longstreet's military career, and indeed, in Confederate history. It is here that the words of disagreement between Longstreet and Lee resonate through Confederate history like an unwelcome truth. As depicted in Ronald Maxwell's 1993 film *Gettysburg*, Longstreet advised Lee, on the second day of the 1863 battle, against a direct assault on the Union center. He advocated for a strategic flanking movement that would force the Union army to attack the Confederates on ground of their choosing. However, Lee, perhaps driven by an overconfidence born from earlier victories or a desire for a decisive victory on Northern soil, chose a different path.
On July 3, 1863, Lee made preparations for an assault on the center of the Union line at Gettysburg. His senior subordinate, Lieutenant General James Longstreet, voiced objections to this plan, famously stating, "General, I have been a soldier all my life. I have been with soldiers engaged in fights by couples, by squads, companies, regiments, divisions, and armies, and should know, as well as any one, what soldiers can do. It is my opinion that no fifteen thousand men ever arrayed for battle can take that position." Despite his strong reservations, Longstreet, as a loyal subordinate, carried out Lee's orders, albeit with a heavy heart. The resulting Pickett's Charge, a frontal assault across open ground, proved to be a catastrophic failure for the Confederacy, marking the high-water mark of the rebellion and a turning point in the war.
For generations, Longstreet was blamed by some Confederate sympathizers and Lost Cause advocates for the defeat at Gettysburg, accused of slowness or insubordination. However, modern historical scholarship largely refutes these claims, recognizing his sound strategic advice and his loyal, if reluctant, execution of orders. His objections were not born of cowardice but of a clear understanding of military realities. The controversy surrounding his role at Gettysburg underscores the profound impact of this battle on the collective memory of the Civil War. In 1998, an equestrian statue was installed of James Longstreet, one of the Confederacy’s most successful generals, present at the battle but never before memorialized at Gettysburg, a belated recognition of his significant, albeit complicated, presence on that hallowed ground.
Post-War Life: Controversy and Redemption
If James Longstreet's wartime career was marked by strategic disagreements, his post-war life was defined by even greater controversy. He became reviled by generations of white southerners as an apostate—both for criticizing the generalship of Robert E. Lee and, perhaps more significantly, for becoming a Republican and supporting black voting and interracial governance during Reconstruction. This political shift, from a prominent Confederate general to a supporter of the very federal government he fought against and an advocate for African American rights, was anathema to many in the defeated South.
Longstreet's embrace of the Republican Party, the party of Abraham Lincoln and Reconstruction, was seen as a betrayal of the Southern cause and its ideals. His willingness to speak out against the "Lost Cause" narrative, which glorified the Confederacy and downplayed the role of slavery, further alienated him from his former comrades and the white Southern establishment. He accepted appointments from Republican presidents, including Ulysses S. Grant, his old friend from West Point and the Mexican War, serving as a surveyor of customs in New Orleans. His commitment to Reconstruction policies was not merely rhetorical; it was active and often dangerous.
In a striking example of his dedication to the new order, James Longstreet, at the head of the largely black Louisiana State Militia, was shot and briefly held prisoner during a riot in New Orleans, Louisiana, in 1874. The rioters were members of the Crescent City White League, a white supremacist organization attempting to overthrow the government of Louisiana. This incident highlights the intense racial and political tensions of the Reconstruction era and Longstreet's courageous, albeit perilous, stand for federal authority and civil rights. To be sure, Longstreet had a lot to be mopey about, facing ostracism and even violence for his convictions. His actions during Reconstruction, though unpopular at the time among many white Southerners, reveal a man who, having fought for the Confederacy, was willing to accept the outcome of the war and work towards a more inclusive future for the nation.
The Legacy of James Longstreet
General James Longstreet is remembered by many as a prominent Confederate general during the American Civil War, a key figure in the Army of Northern Virginia, and "Lee's old war horse." However, his legacy is far more nuanced than a simple military epithet. He stands as a testament to the complexities of history and the individuals who shape it. For decades after the war, his reputation was largely shaped by the "Lost Cause" narrative, which sought to blame him for Gettysburg and demonize him for his post-war political choices. This narrative, perpetuated by figures like Jubal Early, painted him as a disloyal subordinate and an apostate.
Yet, in recent decades, historical scholarship has undergone a significant reassessment of James Longstreet. Historians now largely acknowledge his strategic brilliance, his steadfastness in battle, and the soundness of his tactical advice at Gettysburg. His post-war actions, once condemned, are now often viewed through a more sympathetic lens, recognizing his courage in advocating for reconciliation and racial equality during a deeply divided period. The installation of his equestrian statue at Gettysburg, though still a subject of debate for some, symbolizes this shift in historical perception, recognizing his undeniable importance to the battle and the war, independent of the controversies that once clouded his name.
Longstreet's story serves as a powerful reminder that historical figures are rarely one-dimensional. He was a man of contradictions: a fierce Confederate warrior who later championed the rights of African Americans, a loyal subordinate who openly disagreed with his revered commander. His life offers valuable insights into the profound challenges of war, defeat, and national reconciliation, making him a compelling subject for study for anyone interested in the true intricacies of American history.
Conclusion: A Complex Legacy
James Longstreet's journey from a young West Point graduate to one of the Confederacy's most formidable generals, and then to a controversial figure in Reconstruction-era politics, encapsulates the tumultuous period of American history he inhabited. He was "Old Pete," "my old war horse" to Lee, a trusted advisor whose military acumen was undeniable. Yet, his willingness to challenge conventional wisdom, both on the battlefield and in the political arena, ensured that his legacy would be anything but simple.
His strategic disagreements at Gettysburg, once used to tarnish his reputation, are now largely seen as evidence of his foresight. His post-war support for black voting and interracial governance, though earning him the scorn of many white Southerners, showcases a remarkable willingness to adapt and advocate for a more just society in the face of intense opposition. James Longstreet remains a figure of enduring fascination, a general who not only fought bravely but also dared to think independently and act on his convictions, leaving behind a legacy that continues to spark debate and inspire reflection. We encourage you to delve deeper into the life of this extraordinary figure and share your thoughts in the comments below. What aspects of James Longstreet's life do you find most compelling?
A crown all his own: LeBron James gets NBA's all-time scoring mark his
LeBron James breaks NBA all-time scoring record, surpassing Kareem
2023 NBA All-Star Game starters: LeBron James, Giannis Antetokounmpo
